Consensus Web

July 18, 2008

Expecting the Unexpected, But Not Finding It

Here's something I just came across that stopped me in my tracks:

Homophily makes you stupid.

I get kind of buzzed when I find something that excites me, but I might not have found it before. A web site, news article, book, podcast - almost any bit of information can surprise and delight me when I'm not expecting it. I end up liking it, but wouldn't know that I did before I somehow stumbled across it.

Jon Udell talks about this in a recent blog post. But what I like most here is the idea that you don't too much find these sorts of things when you rely on recommendations from like minded people.

That's a problem for me in Friendfeed and other social sites these days. I liked the flow of stuff from the early tech adopters who hang out on these sites - at least, for a while. But it gets old when the range of subjects posted and discussed doesn't change that much from day to day.

Sure, it's easy enough to filter out stuff you don't want to be exposed to anymore. But how about filtering in stuff you might like to be exposed to? I don't know how to do that, and I'd like to.

Not much encouraging news here, at least not from Udell:

Recommendation systems don’t help me much. They only suggest things similar to other things I’ve shown interest in. Increasingly that just frustrates me. The most delightful recommendations are those that connect me with things that interest me in unpredictable ways. That happens serendipitously, and I haven’t yet found a reliable way to manufacture the serendipity.

Me either. I do like Stumbleupon, a web app that takes you to random pages with the press of a button. It sometimes works, but not enough to feed my appetite for serendipity.

Anybody have some ideas here?

July 14, 2007

Another mobile post

trying to post from iPhone again, this time using the code setting. Which seems to work fairly well, with full use of the predictive typing on the keyboard. Not sure how I'd handle HTML tags though. Better than the last time I tried it, so that's good.Grown to love the predictive typing. It would be nice to have for any keyboard Any day.

May 31, 2006

Smart Web Filters? Maybe Not

Smart Web Filters? Maybe Not

I wrote earlier (on my wordpress blog) about collaborative web filters, especially the Cool Tools mini review that kicked off my interest. The idea of such filters (Newvine, Digg, etc.) is the visibility of the web-based information submitted to them depends on a kind of collaborative voting by the sites' members and ranking figured out by some sort of complex algorithm buried in the code behind the scenes. 

Are the many smarter than the individual, as far as web information filtering goes? The original Cool Tools article seemed to be nodding yes, but Jaron Lanier points out some very thoughtful objections to the view in DIGITAL MAOISM:The Hazards of the New Online Collectivism.

I read Lanier's theme as something like the collective isn't always better, and in fact can be given to being pretty foolish -- at least when it takes information out of the context of provided by smart (or not so smart) individuals.

  • What makes a market work, for instance, is the marriage of collective and individual intelligence. A marketplace can’t exist only on the basis of having prices determined by competition. It also needs entrepreneurs to come up with the products that are competing in the first place.

There's much to recommend spending some time with Lanier's essay. Of course, that's just my individual recommendation.

Welcome

Lijit

About

  • Tom Landini posts stuff to Breathe In, Breathe Out as the mood strikes him, but fairly regularly. Mostly it's about news items that relate to the Feldenkrais Method, how the brain represents sensing and movement or other topics.
  • Breathe In, Breathe Out ... Move On is a lyric from a Jimmy Buffet song of the same name. And it's darned good advice if you ask me.